Exercise 1.3.12

Example 1.3.2 discusses Bombelli’s discovery that 2 + 11 i 3 = 2 + i . But not all cube roots can be expressed so simply. This exercise will show that 4 + 11 i 3 is not of the form a + b 11 i for a , b .

(a)
Suppose that 4 + 11 i = ( a + b 11 i ) 3 for some a , b . Show that this implies that 4 = a 3 33 a b 2 and 1 = 3 a 2 b 11 b 3 .
(b)
Show that the equations of part (a) imply that b = ± 1 and a 4 . Conclude that the equation 4 + 11 i = ( a + b 11 i ) 3 has no solutions with a , b .
(c)
Find a cubic polynomial of the form x 3 + px + q with p , q which has the number 4 + 11 i 3 + 4 11 i 3 as a root.

Answers

Proof.

(a)
Let a , b : ( a + ib 11 ) 3 = a 3 + 3 i a 2 b 11 3 × 11 a b 2 i b 3 11 11 = ( a 3 33 a b 2 ) + i 11 ( 3 a 2 b 11 b 3 ) ,

so, using the irrationality of 11 ,

4 + i 11 = ( a + ib 11 ) 3 { 4 = a 3 33 a b 2 , 1 = 3 a 2 b 11 b 3 .

(b)

The first equation show that a 4 , and the second that b 1 , thus b = ± 1 .

As b 3 = b = ± 1 , the second equation gives 3 a 2 11 = ± 1 , thus 3 a 2 = 10 or 3 a 2 = 12 . 3 a 2 = 10 is impossible since 3 10 . 3 a 2 = 12 gives a = ± 2 . But then 4 = a 3 33 a b 2 = a ( a 2 33 ) = ± 2 × 29 , which is false.

The equation 4 + i 11 = ( a + ib 11 ) 3 has no solution.

(c)
We must find p , q such that q 2 = 4 , ( q 2 ) 2 + ( p 3 ) 3 = 11 .

q = 8 , p = 9 is a solution.

An equation with solution 4 + 11 i 3 + 4 11 i 3 is so

y 3 9 y 8 = 0 .

User profile picture
2022-07-19 00:00
Comments