Exercise 14.1.7

Use Lemma 14.1.3 and part (a) of Lemma 14.1.2 to give a proof of part (b) of Lemma 14.1.2 that doesn’t use the Sylow Theorems.

Answers

Proof. Assume that τ S p satisfies τ𝜃 τ 1 AGL ( 1 , 𝔽 p ) . Then, since 𝜃 is a group of order p , τ𝜃 τ 1 = τ 𝜃 τ 1 is a subgroup of AGL ( 1 , 𝔽 p ) of order p and each element of this subgroup has order p (or 1 ).

By part (a) of Lemma 14.1.2, AGL ( 1 , 𝔽 p ) is the normalizer of 𝜃 in S p , therefore 𝜃 is normal in AGL ( 1 , 𝔽 p ) , with [ AGL ( 1 , 𝔽 p ) : 𝜃 ] = p 1 . The order of each element of τ 𝜃 τ 1 is relatively prime to p 1 , then, by Lemma 14.1.3, τ 𝜃 τ 1 𝜃 , therefore τ 𝜃 τ 1 = 𝜃 , since both groups have the same order p .

Thus τ normalizes 𝜃 , hence τ AGL ( 1 , 𝔽 p ) . □

User profile picture
2022-07-19 00:00
Comments