Exercise 15.2.1

Give a careful proof of (15.9) using the hints given in the text.

Answers

Proof. By section 15.2, we know that φ is 2 ϖ periodic,

φ ( s + 2 ϖ ) = φ ( s ) , ( s ) .

Moreover, for 1 r 1 , and ϖ 2 s ϖ 2 ,

r = φ ( s ) s = 0 r 1 1 t 4 d t .

Write r = φ ( s ) [ 1 , 1 ] . Then for every s [ ϖ 2 , ϖ 2 ] ,

r = φ ( s ) s = 0 r 1 1 t 4 d t s = 0 r 1 1 τ 4 d τ ( τ = t ) s = 0 r 1 1 τ 4 d τ r = φ ( s )

This proves that

φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) ( ϖ 2 s ϖ 2 ) . (1)

Write M ( s ) the point on the lemniscate with signed arc length s . Consider M = M ( s ) the symmetric point of M ( s ) about the origin. Since the lemniscate is symmetric about the origin, Consider first the case where 0 s ϖ , then the signed arc length is the positive arc length. Let M ( s ) the point on the lemniscate with arc length s . Then the symmetric point M ( s ) about the x -axis is such that r = OM ( s ) = OM ( s ) = r , thus, by definition of φ , φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) . The total arc length from O = M ( 0 ) to O = M ( ϖ ) in the first loop is ϖ , and the symmetry of the lemniscate about the x -axis implies that the arc length ϖ s between M ( s ) and O = M ( ϖ ) is equal to the arc length s between O = M ( 0 ) and M ( s ) , thus s = ϖ s . This proves

φ ( ϖ s ) = φ ( s ) ( 0 s ϖ ) . (2)

Now, if ϖ 2 s ϖ , then 0 ϖ s ϖ 2 , thus, using (1), (2), (3)

{ φ ( s ) = φ ( ϖ s ) = φ ( s ϖ ) = φ ( s + ϖ ) , φ ( s ) = φ ( ϖ ( s ) ) = φ ( s + ϖ ) .

Therefore φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) if ϖ 2 s ϖ . Now, if we suppose ϖ s ϖ 2 , then ϖ 2 s ϖ , so we can apply the last equality to s : φ ( s ) = φ ( ( s ) ) = φ ( s ) . This proves

φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) ( ϖ s ϖ ) . (3)

Using the periodicity, if s , the is some n and s [ ϖ , ϖ [ such that s = 2 + s . Then

φ ( s ) = φ ( s 2 ) = φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) = φ ( s 2 ) = φ ( s ) .

We have proved

φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) ( s ) .

We can now complete (2) to ϖ s 0 . Then 0 s ϖ , and by (2) applied to s , φ ( s + ϖ ) = φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) , thus

φ ( ϖ s ) = φ ( s ϖ ) = φ ( s + ϖ ) = φ ( s )

.

We have proved, for all s ,

φ ( s ) = φ ( s ) φ ( ϖ s ) = φ ( s ) .
User profile picture
2022-07-19 00:00
Comments