Homepage Solution manuals David S. Dummit Abstract Algebra Exercise 0.2.7 ($\sqrt{p}$ is not a rational number)

Exercise 0.2.7 ($\sqrt{p}$ is not a rational number)

If p is a prime prove that there do not exist nonzero integers a and b such that a 2 = p b 2 (i.e., p is not a rational number).

Answers

Proof. Assume for the sake of contradiction that a 2 = p b 2 , where b 0 .

Let d = g . c . d ( a , b ) . Then d > 0 , since b 0 . Put A = a d and B = b d . Then g . c . d ( A , B ) = 1 . Moreover ( a d ) 2 = p ( b d ) 2 , thus

A 2 = p B 2 , g . c . d ( A , B ) = 1 .

Then p A 2 , where p is a prime, therefore p A . So there is some integer k such that A = 𝑝𝑘 . Then p 2 k 2 = p B 2 . Simplifying by p 0 , we obtain p k 2 = B 2 , so p B 2 . Since p is a prime, this shows that p B . Hence p g . c . d ( A , B ) = 1 . But p > 1 , thus p 1 . This is a contradiction, which proves that the only solution of a 2 = p b 2 is ( 0 , 0 ) (i.e., p is not a rational number). □

User profile picture
2026-01-07 10:12
Comments