Homepage › Solution manuals › David S. Dummit › Abstract Algebra › Exercise 1.6.3 (Two isomorphic groups are both abelian or both non abelian)
Exercise 1.6.3 (Two isomorphic groups are both abelian or both non abelian)
If is an isomorphism, prove that is a abelian if and only if is abelian. If is a homomorphism, what additional conditions on (if any) are sufficient to ensure that if is abelian, so is ?
Answers
Proof. Let be an isomorphism, where is an abelian group. If and are any elements of , since is surjective, there are elements such that . Since is abelian, we obtain
This shows that is abelian.
Conversely, suppose that is abelian. Since is also an isomorphism, the preceding result shows that is abelian. So is a abelian if and only if is abelian.
If is abelian and is a surjective homomorphism, the preceding argument shows that is also abelian.
If is not surjective, the following counterexample shows that this is false. Consider the map , where is defined by . Then is a homomorphism (which is not surjective) and is abelian, but is not abelian. □