Homepage Solution manuals David S. Dummit Abstract Algebra Exercise 4.5.27 (If $|G| = 315$ and if $G$ has a normal Sylow $3$-subgroup, then $G$ is abelian)

Exercise 4.5.27 (If $|G| = 315$ and if $G$ has a normal Sylow $3$-subgroup, then $G$ is abelian)

Let G be a group of order 315 which has a normal Sylow 3 -subgroup. Prove that Z ( G ) contains a Sylow 3 -subgroup of G and deduce that G is abelian.

Answers

We mimic the last example of this section (p. 143).

Proof. Here | G | = 3 2 5 7 .

By hypothesis, G has a unique Sylow 3 -subgroup P , of order 9 , which is normal in G .

Since P G , G acts on P by conjugation. This action affords an homomorphism

φ : G Aut ( P ) ,

with kernel ker ( φ ) = C G ( P ) , thus G C G ( H ) is isomorphic to a subgroup T of Aut ( G ) :

G C G ( P ) T Aut ( G ) .

(see Proposition 13 and Corollary 15 p. 133, 134.)

Moreover | P | = 3 2 , thus P is abelian, isomorphic to Z 9 or Z 3 × Z 3 , and by Section 4.3,

| Aut ( P ) | = { φ ( 9 ) = 6 if  P Z 9 , | GL 2 ( 𝔽 3 ) | = 48 if  P Z 3 × Z 3 .

In both cases

| Aut ( P ) | 48 .

Since P is abelian, P C G ( P ) , thus 9 | C G ( P ) | , i.e., | C G ( P ) | = 9 k for some integer k , so

| G C G ( P ) | = 3 2 5 7 9 k = 5 7 k ,

so

| T | = | G C G ( P ) | 35 .

Since | T | is a divisor of | Aut ( P ) | = 48 and 35 , where g . c . d . ( 48 , 35 ) = 1 , then | T | = 1 . Therefore | G C G ( P ) | = 1 , thus G = C G ( P ) . This shows that

P Z ( G ) .

Put G ¯ = G P . Then | G ¯ | = 5 7 = 35 .

By the first example (“groups of order pq”, p. 143), since p = 5 q 1 = 6 , G ¯ is cyclic, so

G ¯ = G P Z 35 .

By the Third Isomorphism Theorem, since P Z ( G ) ,

( G P ) ( Z ( G ) P ) G Z ( G ) .

Therefore G Z ( G ) is a quotient group of the cyclic group G P , so is cyclic. By Exercise 3.1.36, this proves that G is abelian. □

User profile picture
2026-03-19 10:51
Comments