Homepage Solution manuals Ivan Niven An Introduction to the Theory of Numbers Exercise 4.5.9 (Among any ten consecutive integers, at least one is relatively prime to the the product of the others)

Exercise 4.5.9 (Among any ten consecutive integers, at least one is relatively prime to the the product of the others)

Prove that among any ten consecutive integers at least one is relatively prime to the the product of the others. [Remark: if “ten” is replaced by “ n ”, the result is true for every positive integer n 16 , but false for n > 16 . This is not easy to prove; cf. R.J.Evans, “On blocks of n consecutive integers”, Amer. Math. Monthly, 76 (1969), 48.]

Answers

Proof. Consider a block I = [ [ n , n + 9 ] ] of ten consecutive positive integers. If n = 1 , then 1 J is relatively prime to the the product of the others. We can now assume that n 2 .

We prove first that there is an integer s I which is not divisible by 2 , 3 , 5 , 7 .

The block I contains exactly 5 odd integers m , m + 2 , m + 4 , m + 6 , m + 8 . Consider the block J = { m , m + 2 , m + 4 , m + 6 , m + 8 } I of 5 consecutive odd integers. Then J contains at most 2 multiples of 3 , at most one multiple of 5 and at most one multiple of 7 . Therefore after elimination of these multiples, it remains at least one integer s J which is not divisible by 3 , 5 , 7 . Since the elements of J are odd,

2 s , 3 s , 5 s , 7 s ( s I ) .

Since n 2 , then s 2 , and every prime factor p of s satisfies p 11 .

Every other element t of the block I is in the form t = s ± i , where i < 10 . If s and t have some prime common divisor p , then p 11 . But p s and p t , thus p t s = ± i , so p i , where i < 10 , thus p < 10 . Since p 11 , this is a contradiction. This proves that s is relatively prime to every other element of the block I . Therefore s is relatively prime to the product of the others elements of the block.

Among any ten consecutive integers, at least one is relatively prime to the the product of the others. □

User profile picture
2025-03-26 09:53
Comments