Exercise 17.20

Find the boundary and the interior of each of the following subsets of 2:

(a)
A = {x × yy = 0}
(b)
B = {x × yx > 0 and y0}
(c)
C = A B
(d)
D = {x × yx is rational}
(e)
E = {x × y0 < x2 y2 1}
(f)
F = {x × yx0 and y 1x}

Answers

(a) It is easy to show that A is closed so that A¯ = A, and that also A¯ = A so that BdA = A. It is also easy to see that no basis element and therefore no neighborhood of any point in A is contained entirely within A. From this it follows that IntA = .

(b) It is easy to show that B is open so that IntB = B. It is likewise not difficult to prove that B¯ = {x × yx 0}. We then have from Exercise 17.19 part (c) that BdB = B¯ B = {x × yx = 0} {x × yx > 0 and y = 0}.

(c) Here we have that C = A B = {x × yy = 0} {x × yx > 0}. It is then easy to show that the closure is C¯ = {x × yy = 0} {x × yx 0}. We also have that C = {x × yx 0 and y0} so that C¯ = {x × yx 0}. From these we clearly then have

BdC = C¯ ( C)¯ = {x × yx < 0 and y = 0} {x × yx = 0}.

It is also not difficult to show that IntC = {x × yx > 0}.

(d) Clearly we have that D¯ is all of 2 as a consequence of the fact that the rationals are order-dense in the reals. Also, since any neighborhood of any point in D will intersect a point x × y with irrational x, it follows that no point of D is in its interior. Thus, IntD = so that D¯ = IntD BdD = BdD = BdD by Exercise 17.19 part (a), and hence BdD = D¯ = 2.

(e) It should be fairly obvious by this point that

BdE = {x × y |y| = |x|} {x × yx2 y2 = 1}

and IntE = {x × y0 < x2 y2 < 1}. This would be easy but tedious to prove rigorously.

(f) First we clearly have that IntF = {x × yx0 and y < 1x}. We also have that F¯ = {x × yx = 0} {x × yx0 and y 1x}. By Exercise 17.19 part (a) we have that F¯ = IntF BdF and that IntF BdF = so that BdF = F¯ IntF. Thus we have that BdF = {x × yx = 0} {x × yx0 and y = 1x}. Again these facts are not difficult to show rigorously but would be tedious.

User profile picture
2019-12-01 00:00
Comments