Exercise 2.2

Let f : A B and let Ai A and Bi B for i = 0 and i = 1. Show that f1 preserves inclusions, unions, intersections, and differences of sets:

(a)
B0 B1 f1(B0) f1(B1).
(b)
f1(B0 B1) = f1(B0) f1(B1).
(c)
f1(B0 B1) = f1(B0) f1(B1).
(d)
f1(B0 B1) = f1(B0) f1(B1).
Show that f preserves inclusions and unions only:
(e)
A0 A1 f(A0) f(A1).
(f)
f(A0 A1) = f(A0) f(A1).
(g)
f(A0 A1) f(A0) f(A1); show that equality holds if f injective.
(h)
f(A0 A1) f(A0) f(A1); show that equality holds if f injective.

Answers

(a)

Proof. Suppose that B0 B1 and consider any x f1(B0). Then by the definition of a preimage, we have f(x) B0 so that also f(x) B1 since B0 B1. This shows that x f1(B1) again by the definition of a preimage. Thus f1(B0) f1(B1) since x was arbitrary as desired. □

(b)

Proof. We can show this easily using a string of biconditionals. For any x A we have

x f1(B 0 B1) f(x) B0 B1 f(x) B0 f(x) B1 x f1(B 0) x f1(B 1) x f1(B 0) f1(B 1),

which shows the desired result. □

(c)

Proof. We can show this in a very similar manner to what was done in part (b). We have

x f1(B 0 B1) f(x) B0 B1 f(x) B0 f(x) B1 x f1(B 0) x f1(B 1) x f1(B 0) f1(B 1),

for any x A. □

(d)

Proof. This is also shown similarly. For x A we have

x f1(B 0 B1) f(x) B0 B1 f(x) B0 f(x)B1 x f1(B 0) xf1(B 1) x f1(B 0) f1(B 1).

(e)

Proof. Suppose that A0 A1 and consider any y f(A0). Then there is an x A0 where y = f(x) by the definition of an image set. Then also x A1 since A0 A1, from which it follows that y = f(x) f(A1). Therefore f(A0) f(A1) as desired since y was arbitrary. □

(f)

Proof. We can show this easily using a string of biconditionals. For any x A we have

y f(A0 A1) x(x A0 A1 y = f(x)) x[(x A0 x A1) y = f(x)] x[(x A0 y = f(x)) (x A1 y = f(x))] x(x A0 y = f(x)) x(x A1 y = f(x)) y f(A0) y f(A1) y f(A0) f(A1),

which shows the desired result. □

(g)

Proof. Consider any y f(A0 A1) so that there is an x A0 A1 where y = f(x). Hence of course x A0 and x A1. Since also y = f(x), this suffices to show that y f(A0) and y f(A1), and therefore y f(A0) f(A1) as desired.

Now suppose that f is injective and consider any y f(A0) f(A1). Then y f(A0) and y f(A1), from which it follows that there is an x0 A0 where y = f(x0), and an x1 A1 where y = f(x1). We then have f(x0) = y = f(x1) so that x0 = x1 since f is injective. Hence x0 A0 and x0 = x1 A1, so of course x0 A0 A1. Since also y = f(x0), this shows by definition that y f(A0 A1). Therefore f(A0) f(A1) f(A0 A1) since y was arbitrary, which shows the desired equivalence since the other direction was already shown. □

(h)

Proof. Consider any y f(A0) f(A1) so that y f(A0) and yf(A1). Then there is an x A0 where y = f(x). We also have that there is no x A1 such that y = f(x). Since we know that y = f(x) it then has to be that xA1. Hence x A0 A1, so that y f(A0 A1) since of course y = f(x). This shows that f(A0 A1) f(A0) f(A1) as desired since y was arbitrary.

Now suppose that f is injective and consider any y f(A0 A1). Then there is an x A0 A1 where y = f(x) by the definition of an image set. Then x A0 but xA1. It then follows that y f(A0) since y = f(x) and x A0. Consider any x A1. Then it cannot be that y = f(x), because if this were the case then f(x) = y = f(x) so that x = x since f is injective. But we know that x = xA1, which would present a contradiction. So it must be that there is no x A1 where y = f(x), which suffices to show that yf(A1). Therefore y f(A0) f(A1) so that f(A0 A1) f(A0) f(A1) since y was arbitrary. This of course shows equivalence as desired. □

User profile picture
2019-12-01 00:00
Comments