Exercise 9.5

(a)
Use the choice axiom to show that if f : A B is surjective, then f has a right inverse h : B A.
(b)
Show that if f : A B is injective and A is not empty, then f has a left inverse. Is the axiom of choice needed?

Answers

(a)

Proof. Suppose that f : A B is surjective. Now, by the choice axiom, the collection A = P (A) {} is a collection of nonempty sets and thus has a choice function c. Consider any b B and the set Ab = {x Af(x) = b}. Then Ab since f is surjective, and hence Ab A since clearly also Ab A so that Ab P (A). So set h(b) = c(Ab) Ab so that h(b) A since Ab A. Hence h is a function from B to A.

Recall that, by definition, h is a right inverse if and only if f h = iB, which we show presently. So consider any b B and let a = h(b) = c(Ab) Ab so that f(a) = b. Then clearly

(f h)(b) = f(h(b)) = f(a) = b,

which shows that f h = iB since b was arbitrary. Hence h is the right inverse of f. □

(b)

Proof. Suppose that f : A B is injective and A. Then f is a bijection from A to its image f(A) B and hence its inverse f1 is a function from f(A) to A. Now, since A is nonempty, there is an a0 A. So define h : B A by

h(b) = { f1(b)b f(A) a0 bf(A)

for any b B. Recall that h is a left inverse of f if and only if h f = iA by definition, which we show now.

So consider any a A and let b = f(a) so that clearly b f(A). Hence by definition h(b) = f1(b) = f1(f(a)) = a. Finally, we have

(h f)(a) = h(f(a)) = h(b) = a.

This shows that h f = iA since a was arbitrary. Therefore h is a left inverse of f as desired. □

Note that this proof does not require the axiom of choice as we did not need to make a choice for each b B in order to define h as we did in part A.

User profile picture
2019-12-01 00:00
Comments