Exercise 5.2.1

Prove that the set of all finite sets of reals has cardinality 2 0 . We remark here that the set of all countable sets of reals also has cardinality 2 0 , but the proof of this requires the Axiom of Choice.

Answers

Proof. Let F denote the set of all finite sets of reals. First we construct an injective f : F 𝑹 𝑵 So consider any A F . Then | A | = n for an n 𝑵 so that there is a finite sequence a k k n where ran ( a ) = A . Now we define an infinite sequence of reals â 𝑹 𝑵 by

â k = { a k k n (i.e.  0 k < n ) a 0 k n (i.e.  k n )

so that clearly we have ran ( â ) = A as well. Note that this only works if A since otherwise there is no a 0 . In the case where A = we set â k = k for k 𝑵 so that ran ( â ) = 𝑵 . In any case we set f ( A ) = â .

Now we claim that f is injective. So consider any A , B F where A B . If one of them is the empty set, say A , then since B is finite m = max ( max ( B ) + 1 , 0 ) exists so that clearly m B . Hence m ran ( f ( B ) ) = B . However m ran ( f ( A ) ) = 𝑵 since m 𝑵 . It thus follows that ran ( f ( B ) ) ran ( f ( A ) ) so that f ( A ) f ( B ) . On the other hand if neither A nor B is the empty set (but still A B ) then there is an a A where a B or vice versa. Without loss of generality we need only consider the first case. Clearly then a ran ( f ( A ) ) = A but a ran ( f ( B ) ) = B so that again f ( A ) f ( B ) . Hence in all cases we’ve shown that f is injective.

Thus we have that

| F | | 𝑹 𝑵 | = 2 0 ,

where the last equality was shown in Theorem 5.2.3d. Now define

E = { { x } x 𝑹 }

so that clearly E F and | E | = | 𝑹 | . Hence we have

2 0 = | 𝑹 | = | E | | F |

by Exercise 4.1.3. Thus by the Cantor-Bernstein Theorem | F | = 2 0 as required. □

User profile picture
2024-07-15 11:42
Comments