Exercise 9.1.12

Prove the formula

i I ( κ λ i ) = κ i I λ i .

[Hint: Generalize the proof of the special case κ λ κ μ = κ λ + μ given in Theorem 1.7(a) of Chapter 5.]

Answers

Proof. First, suppose that A is a set such that | A | = κ , and that B i i I are mutually disjoint sets such that | B i | = λ i for each i I . Then, by the definitions of cardinal products and sums, we have

i I ( κ λ i ) = i I | A B i | = | i I A B i |

and

κ i I λ i = κ | i I B i | = | A i I B i | .

We now construct a bijective function F from i I A B i to A i I B i , which clearly shows the desired result since we then have

i I ( κ λ i ) = | i I A B i | = | A i I B i | = κ i I λ i .

So, for any f = f i i I i I A B i , we have that each f i is a function from B i to A . It then follows from the fact that B i i I are mutually disjoint that { f i } i I is a compatible system of functions. We then that g = i I f i is a function from i I dom ( f i ) = i I B i to A by Theorem 2.3.12. Hence g A i I B i , and we of course set F ( f ) = g so that F is a function from i I A B i to A i I B i .

To show that F is injective, consider any f and f in i I A B i where f f . Let g = F ( f ) and g = F ( f ) . It then follows that there is an i 0 I such that f i 0 f i 0 . Then, it has to be that there is a b B i 0 where f i 0 ( b ) f i 0 ( b ) . Clearly also b i I B i since i 0 I so that b dom ( g ) and b dom ( g ) (since by the definition of F we have that g and g are functions with domain i I B i ). Moreover, we have that g ( b ) = f i 0 ( b ) and g ( b ) = f i 0 ( b ) , which again follows from the fact that B i i I are mutually disjoint or equivalently that { f i } i I is a compatible system. Hence we have g ( b ) = f i 0 ( b ) f i 0 ( b ) = g ( b ) so that F ( f ) = g g = F ( f ) . This shows that F is injective since f and f were arbitrary.

To see that F is onto, consider any g A i I B i . For each i I , define f i = g B i , which is clearly a function from B i to A so that f i A B i . Then let f = f i i I so that F ( f ) = g = i I f i , and clearly f i I A B i = dom ( F ) . Now consider any ( x , y ) g = i I f i so that there is an i 0 I where ( x , y ) f i 0 = g B i 0 . Therefore ( x , y ) g since obviously g B i 0 g . Consider next any ( x , y ) g so that x dom ( g ) = i I B i and y = g ( x ) . Then there is an i 0 I where x B i 0 so that ( x , y ) g B i 0 = f i 0 . Hence clearly ( x , y ) i I f i = g since i 0 I . Therefore g g and g g so that F ( f ) = g = g , which shows that F is onto since g was arbitrary.

We have thus shown that F is a bijection so that the result follows. □

User profile picture
2024-07-15 11:42
Comments