Exercise 1.21

Prove that ord p ( a + b ) ≥ min ⁡ ( ord p a , ord p b ) with equality holding if ord p a ≠ ord p b .

Answers

Proof. As a ∧ b ∣ a + b , ord p ( a ∧ b ) ≤ ord p ( a + b ) , so min ⁡ ( ord p ( a ) , ord p ( b ) ) ≤ ord p ( a + b ) .

Suppose that ord p ( a ) ≠ ord p ( b ) . The problem being symmetric in a , b , we may suppose α = ord p ( a ) < β = ord p ( b ) . So there exist q , r ∈ ℤ such that

a = p α q , p ∤ q b = p β r , p ∤ r α < β .

Then a + b = p α ( q + p β − α r ) , where p ∤ q + p β − α r (as p ∣ p β − α and p ∤ q ).

So ord p ( a + b ) = α = min ⁡ ( ord p ( a ) , ord p ( b ) ) . □

User profile picture
2022-07-19 00:00
Comments