Exercise 10.17

Show that for each m > 0 and finite field F q there is a form of degree m in m variables with no nontrivial zero. [Hint: Let ω 1 , ω 2 , , ω m be a basis for F q m over F q and show that f ( x 1 , x 2 , , x m ) = i = 0 m 1 ( ω 1 q i x 1 + + ω m q i x m ) has the required properties.]

Answers

Proof. Let ω 1 , ω 2 , , ω m be a basis for F q m over F q .

Consider

f ( x 1 , , x m ) = i = 0 m 1 ( ω 1 q i x 1 + + ω m q i x m ) .

Then f is a form of degree m in m variables.

By definition, f 𝔽 q m ( x 1 , , x m ) . We show first that f 𝔽 q [ x 1 , , x m ] .

Let f be the Frobenius automorphism on 𝔽 q m , defined by

F { 𝔽 q m 𝔽 q m α α q .

By Corollary 1 of Proposition 7.1.1, for every α 𝔽 q m , α 𝔽 q if and only if F ( α ) = α . If p = i = 0 d a i 1 , , i m x 1 i 1 x m i m 𝔽 q m [ x 1 , , x m ] , define F p = i = 0 d F ( a i 1 , , i m ) x 1 i 1 x m i m . Then F p 𝔽 q m [ x ] F p = p and F ( pq ) = ( F p ) ( F q ) for all p , q 𝔽 q m [ x 1 , , x m ] .

Then, using this last property,

F f = i = 0 m 1 F ( ω 1 q i x 1 + + ω m q i x m ) = i = 0 m 1 ( ω 1 q i + 1 x 1 + + ω m q i + 1 x m ) = j = 1 m ( ω 1 q j x 1 + + ω m q j x m ) ( j = i + 1 ) = j = 0 m 1 ( ω 1 q j x 1 + + ω m q j x m ) ( since  ω k q m = ω k = ω k q 0 , k = 1 , , m ) = f .

Therefore f 𝔽 q [ x 1 , , x m ] .

Now we prove that f has no non trivial zero a ¯ = ( α 1 , , α m ) 𝔽 q m { ( 0 , , 0 ) } . If f had such a zero ( α 1 , , α m ) 𝔽 q m , then

i = 0 m 1 ( ω 1 q i α 1 + + ω m q i α m ) = 0 , α 1 , , α m 𝔽 q .

Then for some i [[ 0 , m 1 ]] ,

ω 1 q i α 1 + + ω m q i α m = 0 .

Applying F m i to this equality, and using F ( α i ) = α i , we obtain

ω 1 q m α 1 + + ω m q m α m = 0 .

Since ω i q m = ω i , i = 1 , , m , this gives

ω 1 α 1 + + ω m α m = 0 .

Since ω 1 , ω 2 , , ω m is a basis for F q m over F q , this proves

( α 1 , , α m ) = ( 0 , , 0 ) .

So f has no non trivial zero.

Note : this proves that we cannot extend the Chevalley’s Theorem to the forms of degree m in m varibles. □

User profile picture
2022-07-19 00:00
Comments