Exercise 2.23

Let f ( x ) ∈ ℤ [ x ] and let ψ ( n ) be the number of f ( j ) , j = 1 , 2 , … , n , such that ( f ( j ) , n ) = 1 . Show that ψ ( n ) is multiplicative and that ψ ( p t ) = p t − 1 ψ ( p ) . Conclude that ψ ( n ) = n ∏ ⁡ p | n ψ ( p ) ∕ p .

Answers

Proof. My interpretation of this statement is that ψ ( n ) is the number of j , j = 1 , 2 , … , n , such that ( f ( j ) , n ) = 1 (if f is not one to one, we may obtain a different value).

Let A n = { j ∈ ℤ , 1 ≤ j ≤ n | f ( j ) ∧ n = 1 } . Then ψ ( n ) = | A n | . If f ( x ) = ∑ ⁡ k = 0 d a k x k , note f n ( x ) ∈ ( ℤ ∕ nℤ ) [ x ] the polynomial f n ( x ) = ∑ ⁡ k = 0 n [ a k ] n x k (here, we represent the class of j ∈ ℤ in ℤ ∕ nℤ by [ j ] n ). We can write without inconvenient f = f n .

Let B n = { a ∈ ℤ ∕ nℤ | f ( a ) ∈ ( ℤ ∕ nℤ ) ∗ } , where ( ℤ ∕ nℤ ) ∗ is the group of invertible elements of ℤ ∕ nℤ .

Then u : A n → B n , j ↦ [ j ] n is a bijection.

Indeed u is well defined : if j ∈ A n , f ( j ) ∧ n = 1 , so f ( [ j ] n ) = [ f ( j ) ] n ∈ ( ℤ ∕ nℤ ) ∗ .

u is injective : [ j ] n = [ k ] n with 1 ≤ j ≤ n , 1 ≤ k ≤ n implies j = k .

u is surjective : if a ∈ ℤ ∕ n ∕ Z verifies f ( a ) ∈ ( ℤ ∕ nℤ ) ∗ , let j the unique representative of a such that 1 ≤ j ≤ n . Then f ( j ) ∧ n = 1 , so u ( j ) = a .

Thus

ψ ( n ) = | B n | , where B n = { a ∈ ℤ ∕ nℤ | f ( a ) ∈ ( ℤ ∕ nℤ ) ∗ } .

Suppose n ∧ m = 1 . Let

φ : { B nm → B n × B m [ j ] nm ↦ ( [ j ] n , [ j ] m )

∙ φ is well defined : [ j ] nm = [ k ] nm ⇒ j ≡ k ( mod nm ) ⇒ ( j ≡ k ( mod n ) , j ≡ k ( mod m ) ) ⇒ ( [ j ] n , [ j ] m ) = ( [ k ] n , [ k ] m ) .

∙ φ is injective : if φ ( [ j ] nm ) = φ ( [ k ] nm ) , then [ j ] n = [ k ] n , [ j ] m = [ k ] m , so n ∣ j − k , m ∣ j − k . As n ∧ m = 1 , nm ∣ j − k so [ j ] nm = [ k ] nm .

∙ φ is surjective : if ( a , b ) ∈ B n × B m , there exist j , k ∈ ℤ , 1 ≤ j ≤ n , 1 ≤ j ≤ m , such that a = [ j ] n , b = [ k ] m . From the Chinese Remainder Theorem, there exists i ∈ ℤ , 1 ≤ i ≤ n , such that i ≡ j ( mod n ) , i ≡ k ( mod m ) . Then φ ( [ i ] nm ) = ( [ i ] n , [ i ] m ) = ( [ j ] n , [ k ] m ) = ( a , b ) .

Finally, ψ ( nm ) = | B nm | = | B n | | B m | = ψ ( n ) ψ ( m ) , if n ∧ m = 1 : ψ is a multiplicative function.

The interval I = [ 1 , p t ] is the disjoint reunion of the p t − 1 intervals I k = [ kp + 1 , ( k + 1 ) p ] for k = 0 , 1 , ⋯ , p t − 1 − 1 , so ψ ( p t ) = ∑ ⁡ k = 0 p t − 1 − 1 Card C k , where C k = { j ∈ I k | f ( j ) ∧ p t = 1 } = { j ∈ I k | f ( j ) ∧ p = 1 } .

As f ( j ) ∧ p = 1 ⟺ f ( j − kp ) ∧ p = 1 , the application v : C k → C 0 , j ↦ j − kp is well defined and is bijective, so | C k | = | C 0 | = ψ ( p ) . Thus ψ ( p t ) = p t − 1 Card I 0 = p t − 1 ψ ( p ) :

ψ ( p t ) = p t − 1 ψ ( p ) .

If n = ∏ ⁡ p ∣ n p t ( p ) , then

ψ ( n ) = ∏ p ∣ n ψ ( p t ( p ) ) = ∏ p ∣ n p t ( p ) − 1 ψ ( p ) = n ∏ p ∣ n ψ ( p ) p □
User profile picture
2022-07-19 00:00
Comments