Exercise 3.5.5

Show that it is impossible to write

R = n = 1 F n

where for each n N , F n is a closed set containing no nonempty open intervals.

Answers

This is just the complement of Exercise 3.5.4, If we had R = n = 1 F n then we would also have

= n = 1 G n

for G n = F n c . G n is open as it is the complement of a closed set, and since F n contains no nonempty open intervals G n is dense. This contradicts n = 1 G n from 3.5.4.

To be totally rigorous we still have to justify F n c being dense. Let a , b R with a < b , since ( a , b ) F n there exists a c ( a , b ) with c F n c and thus F n c is dense.

User profile picture
2022-01-27 00:00
Comments