Homepage › Solution manuals › Stephen Abbott › Understanding Analysis › Exercise 4.3.14
Exercise 4.3.14
- (a)
- Let be a closed set. Construct a function such that the set of points where fails to be continuous is precisely . (The concept of the interior of a set, discussed in Exercise 3.2.14, may be useful.)
- (b)
- Now consider an open set . Construct a function whose set of discontinuous points is precisely . (For this problem, the function in Exercise 4.3.12 may be useful.)
Answers
- (a)
-
Using the notation from Exercise 3.2.14, note that
and
are disjoint but their union is
; moreover
. Let
denote Dirichlet’s function (1 on rationals, 0 on irrationals), and consider
If (which is open) then we can find where there will be both irrational and rational numbers, indicating that is discontinuous over .
If , must be a limit point of , and therefore all will intersect at some point, and thus for some , preventing from being continuous in .
If (which is open) then we can find which is a constant 3, and therefore is continuous over . Thus, is discontinous only over .
- (b)
-
Define
for and by choosing we will have for (simply consider ) implying is continuous over .
Since is open, for any given we can find so that for all . (One way to do this is by choosing so that , taking , noting that , and concluding that .) Then since for any , there must be points where , it must be impossible to satisfy the definition of continuity for (since in the -neighbourhood of , will jump by at least that amount between rational and irrational numbers), and therefore is discontinuous for any .