Exercise 6.2.10

This exercise and the next explore partial converses of the Continuous Limit Theorem (Theorem 6.2.6). Assume f n f pointwise on [ a , b ] and the limit function f is continuous on [ a , b ] . If each f n is increasing (but not necessarily continuous), show f n f uniformly.

Answers

f is continuous and therefore will map [ a , b ] to a closed interval [ c , d ] . By the Order Limit Theorem, we also know that f must be increasing - just compare the sequence lim n f n ( x 1 ) to lim n f n ( x 2 ) when x 2 > x 1 .

The key implication of f n and f being increasing is that there is a bound to how fast the error | f f n | can grow with respect to x , which is proportional to how fast f grows. Intuitively, if we have f > f n and want the error to grow as fast as possible with respect to x , all we can do is hold f n constant. Alternatively, if we have f < f n , f n can’t go too far above f since f needs to catch up eventually.

More formally, for 𝜖 > 0 , define y 1 , y 2 , y 3 , , y n to evenly split up [ c , d ] into intervals of size at most 𝜖 1 = 𝜖 5 . (In other words, y 1 = c , y n = d , y k + 2 y k + 1 = y k + 1 y k < 𝜖 1 .) Since f is increasing, we can define x 1 , , x n so that f ( x k ) = y k .

Since f n f , we can find M k so that m k > M k implies | y k f m k ( x k ) | < 𝜖 1 . Let M = max { M 1 , M 2 , , M n } . Now, let m > M be arbitrary. Keeping in mind that f m is increasing, we can bound f m ( x i + 1 ) f m ( x i ) by

f m ( x i + 1 ) f m ( x i ) = | f m ( x i + 1 ) f m ( x i ) | | f m ( x i + 1 ) y i + 1 | + | y i + 1 y i | + | y i f m ( x i ) | < 𝜖 1 + 𝜖 1 + 𝜖 1 = 3 𝜖 1

Now consider | f ( x ) f m ( x ) | x [ x i , x i + 1 ] with i arbitrary. Since f is increasing, y i f ( x ) y i + 1 , so f ( x ) y i < 𝜖 1 . Similarly f m ( x ) f m ( x i ) f m ( x i + 1 ) f m ( x i ) < 3 𝜖 1 . Finally, we have

| f ( x ) f m ( x ) | = | f ( x ) y i | + | y i f m ( x i ) | + | f m ( x ) f m ( x i ) | < 𝜖 1 + 𝜖 1 + 3 𝜖 1 = 𝜖

Since m and i were arbitrary, this completes the proof.

User profile picture
2022-01-27 00:00
Comments