Homepage › Solution manuals › Stephen Abbott › Understanding Analysis › Exercise 8.4.19
Exercise 8.4.19
- (a)
-
Although we verified it directly, show how to use the theorems in this section to give a second justification for the formula
- (b)
-
Now derive the formula
Answers
- (a)
-
We would like to use Theorem 8.4.9, with
and
. We already have that
exists for
. So, we need to show that
and
are continuous and that
converges uniformly.
Let’s first show that is continuous. For any fixed and , we want , that whenever , that
Since is continuous, we can find so that
Now if , , and , then
We can ensure both of these conditions by setting , thus showing is continuous.
It’s fairly easy to show that if is continuous, so is . Additionally, a careful re-reading of the proofs for Theorem 4.2.3 (Sequential Criterion for Functional Limits) and Exercise 4.2.1 (Algebraic Limit Theorem for Functional Limits) show that they can be reused for complete metric spaces such as with the usual metric. Thus Theorem 4.3.4 (Algebraic Continuity Theorem) can also be generalized to , and we can conclude for any , the function is continuous. Thus, both and are continuous.
Now we need to show converges uniformly when . To make part (b) easier we’ll prove the more general statement that converges uniformly, for any with . As a prerequisite, note that if converges uniformly, then so does , provided is well defined.
We can adapt the solution to Exercise 8.4.5 to show that for any , , . Thus, for any fixed , we can find some so that converges uniformly, by Exercise 8.4.16 (variant of the Weierstrauss M-Test) and comparison against . This in turn shows that converges uniformly.
Finally, before applying Theorem 8.4.9 to get our desired result, we need to define the domain . For a given , we want to contain all points of the form , so define .
- (b)
- This is just a repeated application of Theorem 8.4.9 on the formula proved in part (a); the solution to part (a) shows that all of the prerequisites to Theorem 8.4.9 are always met in this process.