Homepage Solution manuals Terence Tao An Introduction to Measure Theory Exercise 1.6.2 (Everywhere differentiable function not necessarily continuously differentiable)

Exercise 1.6.2 (Everywhere differentiable function not necessarily continuously differentiable)

Give an example of a function F : [a,b] which is everywhere differentiable, but not continuously differentiable.

Answers

Consider the function that vanishes quickly at 0, yet also oscillates rapidly near that point:

f : [1,1] ,f(x) = { sin (1 x ) x2if x0 0 if x = 0

PIC

Figure 1: Plot of the function f(x) = sin (1 x ) x, which is diferrentiable but has a non-continuous derivative.

Notice that on the domain [1,1]{0} both functions sin (1x) and x are differentiable (cf. Analysis II, section 4.7), and so is their composition and product (cf. Analysis I, Theorem 10.1.13 and 10.1.15). Thus, f is differentiable on [1,1]{0} with derivative (see derivative rules)

f(x) = cos (1 x ) 1 x + sin (1 x ).

What about the point 0? Using raw machinery, we calculate the value of the derivative at this point:

f(0) = lim x0 sin (1 x ) x2 0 x 0 = sin (1 x ) x 0.

But lim x0f(x) diverges, since sin (1x) part of it is periodic. Thus, lim x0f(x)f(0), and f is not continuous.

User profile picture
2021-01-06 00:00
Comments