Homepage Solution manuals Theodore Gamelin Introduction to Topology Exercise 2.1.5 (Limit points and isolated points)

Exercise 2.1.5 (Limit points and isolated points)

Let S be a subset of a topological space X in which sets consisting of one point are closed. A point x X is a limit point of S if every neighborhood of x contains a point of S other than x itself. A point s S is an isolated point of S if there is a neighborhood U of s such that U S = {s}. Show that the set of limit points of S is closed. Show that S is the disjoint union of the set of limit points of S and the isolated points of S.

Answers

Let λS denote the set of all limit points of S, and let ιS denote the set of isolated points of S.

Proof. The trick is to consider the closure λS¯ of the limit points of S and to notice that by definition of an adherent point, any point x λS¯ must have a limit point x λS in every one of its neighbourhoods U x and thus meet S as well (e.g. intersect neighbourhoods of both x and x). Since U {x} is open (as a set difference of an open and a closed set), we have proven that x is a limit point of S, i.e., λS¯ = λS. By Theorem 1.3, λS is closed. □

We now demonstrate that the closure S¯ of S can be partitioned as S¯ = λS ιS.

Proof. Let x be from the right-hand side. Then x is either an isolated point or a limit point (clearly not both, hence the disjointness). If x is an isolated point, then x S S¯ by definition; if x is a limit point, then x is obviously adherent und thus x S¯.
Conversely, suppose that x S¯. We have two cases: either x S or x S¯ S. Notice how the definitions of limit and isolated points are complementary in S; a point x S would either be a limit point or an isolated point. In case that x S¯ S, x must be on the outside of S and cannot be an isolated point of S. It is, however, adherent to S and must thus be a limit point of S. □

User profile picture
2022-06-30 11:46
Comments