Homepage Solution manuals Theodore Gamelin Introduction to Topology Exercise 2.3.1 (Topological continuity generalizes metric continuity)

Exercise 2.3.1 (Topological continuity generalizes metric continuity)

Let f be a function from a metric space X to a metric space Y and let x X. Show that the definition of continuity of f at x given in this section (for each open neighborhood V of f(x), there exists an open neighborhood U of x such that f(U) V ) coincides with the definition given in Section I. 6 (whenever {xn} is a sequence in X such that xn x, then f (xn) f(x)).

Answers

Proof. We demonstrate both directions of the equivalence.

Suppose that the topological continuity holds, i.e., for each open neighbourhood V of f(x), there exists an open neighbourhood U of x such that f(U) V . Let {xn} be an arbitrary sequence converging to x, i.e,

δ > 0N n N : xn B(x,δ).
(1)

To demonstrate that f(xn) x, pick an arbitrary 𝜖 > 0. By the assumption, we can find an open neighbourhood B(x,δ) U of x such that f(B(x,δ)) B(f(x),𝜖). Using 1 ,

N n N : f(xn) f(B(x,δ)) B(f(x),𝜖),

which is just another way of saying that {f(xn)} converges to f(x).

Suppose that the metric continuity holds, i.e., whenever {xn} is a sequence in X such that xn x, then f (xn) f(x). Let V be an arbitrary open neighbourhood of f(x) and suppose for the sake of contradiction that no open neighbourhood U of x satisfies f(U) V . In particular,

n : f (B (x, 1 n ))B(f(x),𝜖)

for some B(f(x),𝜖) V (for 𝜖 > 0 small enough). By axiom of choice, we can construct a sequence xn B (x, 1 n ) and would get f(xn)↛f(x) by construction - a contradiction.

User profile picture
2022-07-09 11:18
Comments