Exercise 2.9

Suppose X , Y , Z are Banach spaces and

B : X × Y Z

is bilinear and continuous. Prove that there exists M < such that

B ( x , y ) M x x ( x X , y Y ) .

Is completeness needed here?

Answers

The answer is: No. To prove this, we only assume that X , Y , Z are normed spaces. Since B is continous at the origin, there exists a positive r such that

x + y < r B ( x , y ) < 1 . (1)

Given nonzero x , y , let s range over ] 0 , r [ , so that the folllowing bound

B ( x , y ) = 4 x y s 2 B ( s 2 x x , s 2 y y ) < ( 1 ) 4 x y s 2 (2)

is effective. It is now obvious that

B ( x , y ) 4 s 2 x y s r 4 r 2 x y ( ( x , y ) X × Y ) ; (3)

which achieves the proof.

As a concrete example, choose X = Y = Z = C c ( R ) , topologized by the supremum norm. C c ( R ) is not complete (see 5.4.4 of Laurent Schwartz’ Analyse III (in French), Hermann, 1997.), nevertheless the bilinear product

B : C c ( R ) 2 C c ( R ) ( f , g ) f g

is bounded (since f g f g ), and continuous. To show this, pick a positive scalar 𝜖 smaller than 1 , provided any ( f , g ) . Next, define

r 𝜖 1 + f + g < 1 . (4)

We now restrict ( u , v ) to a particular neighborhood of ( f , g ) . More specifically,

f u + g v < r . (5)

Next, remark that u r + f and so obtain (bear in mind that r < 1 )

f g u v = ( f u ) g + u ( g v ) (6) f u g + u g v (7) < r g + ( r + f ) r (8) < r ( r + f + g ) (9) < 𝜖 . (10)

Since 𝜖 was arbitrary, it is now established that B continuous at every ( f , g ) .

User profile picture
2020-01-24 00:00
Comments