Exercise 2.18

Exercise 18: Is there a nonempty perfect set in which contains no rational number?

Answers

Yes. Here is one example: Choose two irrational numbers, e.g. α = 2 and β = 3 , and let { a n } be an enumeration of the rational numbers in E 1 = [ α , β ] .

Let r 1 be the first element of { a n } that is in E 1 , and pick irrational numbers α 1 < r 1 , β 1 > r 1 such that α < α 1 < r 1 < β 1 < β . By removing the interval ( α 1 , β 1 ) , we end up with a union of closed intervals

E 2 = [ α , α 1 ] [ β 1 , β ]

By repeating this process for each closed interval in this union and continuing this process in the same vein as the construction of the Cantor set, we end up with a sequence of compact sets

E 1 E 2

Now consider E = n = 1 E n . The reasoning on p. 41 carries through with small modifications, so that we can deduce that E is perfect. By construction, there are no rational numbers in E .

User profile picture
2023-08-07 00:00
Comments