Exercise 5.15

Exercise 15: Suppose a R , f is twice-differentiable real function on ( a , ) , and M 0 , M 1 , M 2 are the least upper bounds of | f ( x ) | , | f ( x ) | , | f ( x ) | , respectively, on ( a , ) . Prove that M 1 2 4 M 0 M 2 .

To show that M 1 2 = 4 M 0 M 2 can actually happen, take a = 1 , define

f ( x ) = { 2 x 2 1 ( 1 < x < 0 ) x 2 1 x 2 + 1 ( 0 x < )

and show that M 0 = 1 , M 1 = 4 , M 2 = 4 .

Does M 1 2 4 M 0 M 2 hold for vector-valued functions too?

Answers

Let g ( x ) = A x + Bx for x > 0 where A and B are positive real numbers. Then g ( x ) = A x 2 + B and g ( x ) = 2 A x 3 > 0 . Since g ( x ) = 0 for x = A B , g has the minimum value g ( A B ) = 2 AB .

Following the hint, by Theorem 5.15, for h > 0 there is ξ ( x , x + 2 h ) such that

f ( x + 2 h ) = f ( x ) + 2 h f ( x ) + 2 h 2 f ( ξ ) f ( x ) = f ( x + 2 h ) f ( x ) 2 h h f ( ξ )

Hence | f ( x ) | M 0 h + M 2 h 2 M 0 M 2 by the previous result, or M 1 2 4 M 0 M 2 .

Letting f ( x ) be the example above, we get

f ( x ) = { 4 x ( 1 < x < 0 ) 4 x ( x 2 + 1 ) 2 ( 0 < x < ) f ( x ) = { 4 ( 1 < x < 0 ) 4 ( 1 3 x 2 ) ( x 2 + 1 ) 3 ( 0 < x < )

f ( 3 ) ( x ) = { 0 ( 1 < x < 0 ) 48 x ( x 2 1 ) ( x 2 + 1 ) 4 ( 0 < x < )

For x < 0 , f is negative, so f ( x ) decreases from 1 to 1 , and for x > 0 , f is positive, so f ( x ) increases monotonically from 1 to a limit of 1 . Hence M 0 = 1 .

For x < 0 , f increases linearly from 4 to 0. For x > 0 , f ( x ) = 0 has a single solution at x = 3 3 , so f ( x ) has a maximum value of 3 3 4 . Hence M 1 = 4 .

For x > 0 , f ( 3 ) ( x ) has the single solution x = 1 , so f ( x ) decreases from 4 to a minimum value of f ( 1 ) = 1 , then increases monotonically to a limit of 0. Hence M 2 = 4 .

Hence for this example, M 1 2 = 4 M 0 M 1 = 16 .

User profile picture
2023-08-07 00:00
Comments