Exercise 5.26

Exercise 26: Suppose f is differentiable on [ a , b ] , f ( a ) = 0 , and there is a real number A such that | f ( x ) | A | f ( x ) | on [ a , b ] . Prove that f ( x ) = 0 for all x [ a , b ] .

Answers

I’m going to show this for vector-valued functions f = ( f 1 , , f k ) mapping [ a , b ] into R k such that f ( a ) = 0 and such that | f ( x ) | A | f ( x ) | , since this is needed for Exercise 28.

If A = 0 , then f = 0 , so f = f ( a ) = 0 by Theorem 5.11(b). So assume that A > 0 . Following the hint, let δ > 0 be small enough so that δ < 1 A and x 0 = a + δ b . For i = 1 , , k , let M i , 0 = sup | f i ( x ) | , M i , 1 = sup | f i ( x ) | for a x x 0 . By Theorem 5.19, for any x ( a , x 0 ) and for every i = 1 , , k there is a t i ( a , x ) such that

| f i ( x ) | = | f i ( x ) f i ( a ) | = | f i ( t ) | ( x a ) M i , 1 ( x a ) A M i , 0 δ .

Since < 1 , this can only happen if M i , 0 = 0 , so f i ( x ) = 0 in [ a , a + δ ] for each i = 1 , , k , that is, f = 0 in [ a , a + δ ] . Repeating this argument with a + δ replacing a , we get f ( x ) = 0 in [ a , a + 2 δ ] . After about ( b a ) δ steps, we’ve shown that f ( x ) = 0 in [ a , b ] .

User profile picture
2023-08-07 00:00
Comments