Exercise 7.9

Exercise 9: Let { f n } be a sequence of continuous functions which converges uniformly to a function f on a set E . Prove that

lim n f n ( x n ) = f ( x )

for every sequence of points x n E such that x n x , and x E . Is the converse of this true?

Answers

The problem didn’t state it explicitly, but in order to apply the Chapter’s Theorems let’s assume that E is a set in a metric space.

Let 𝜀 > 0 . Since { f n } converges uniformly to f , there is an integer N 1 such that if n N 1 then for any y E we have

| f n ( y ) f ( y ) | < 𝜀 2 .

Since f is continuous by Theorem 7.12, there is an integer N 2 such that if n N 2 then

| f ( x n ) f ( x ) | < 𝜀 2 .

Hence, if n max ( N 1 , N 2 ) , we have

| f n ( x n ) f ( x ) | | f n ( x n ) f ( x n ) | + | f ( x n ) f ( x ) | < 𝜀 .

The converse is not true. For example, let E = [ 0 , 1 ) and let f n ( x ) = x n . Then this sequence converges to the constant function f ( x ) = 0 , but not uniformly. If { x n } is a sequence of points of E converging to a point x in E , then it is contained in a closed subinterval [ 0 , a ] where a < 1 . Since f n converges uniformly on this subinterval, f n ( x n ) converges to f ( x ) by the first part of this problem. Hence this property is insufficient for determining that the convergence is uniform.

User profile picture
2023-08-07 00:00
Comments