Exercise 1.1

Does there exist an infinite σ -algebra which has only countably many members?

Answers

Proof. We claim any infinite σ -algebra must be uncountable. For suppose not, and S = { A i } i = 1 is our countable σ -algebra on a set X . Then, for each x X , let B x : = x A i A i ; then B x S . We first claim that if B x B y , then B x = B y . For suppose z B x B y . Then, B z B x , and if x B z , then B x B z B x , contradicting the definition of B x . Thus, B x = B z = B y .

Now consider { B x } x X . Then, X = x X B x , and if there are only finitely many distinct B x , then S is also finite, a contradiction. So, there are infinitely many B x , and the cardinality of S must be at least 2 N . □

User profile picture
2021-12-22 00:00
Comments