Exercise 2.7.14

Is it possible for a real matrix A that Ran A = Ker A T ? Is it possible for a complex A ?

Answers

Solution Both are not possible. Suppose A is m × n and Ran A = Ker AT. Then Ran A Ker AT, i.e., ATAv = 0 for any v n. This holds only when ATA = 0n×n. Then A = 0m×n. (Use the row vectors of AT and check the diagonal entries of ATA equal to 0. It will lead to the conclusion that the row vectors are all-zero vectors.)

On the other hand, if Ran A = Ker AT, Ker AT Ran A. i.e., if ATb = 0, then the function Ax = b has a solution. But we have A = 0m×n, then for arbitrary b m, ATb = 0 holds. But for b0, Ax = b does not have a solution. This is contradictory. So it is not possible for the real or complex matrix A that Ran A = Ker AT.

User profile picture
2018-11-29 00:00
Comments
  • This solution is incorrect, the result can be true for complex matrices, for example the one in the previous exercise. Note that in this proof $A^TAv=0$ does not necessarily imply $A=0$ if $A$ is complex.
    introspectiveSwallow2024-08-15