Homepage › Solution manuals › Sergei Treil › Linear Algebra Done Wrong › Exercise 2.7.14
Exercise 2.7.14
Is it possible for a real matrix that Ran Ker ? Is it possible for a complex ?
Answers
Solution Both are not possible. Suppose is and Ran Ker . Then Ran Ker , i.e., for any . This holds only when . Then . (Use the row vectors of and check the diagonal entries of equal to 0. It will lead to the conclusion that the row vectors are all-zero vectors.)
On the other hand, if Ran Ker , Ker Ran . i.e., if , then the function has a solution. But we have , then for arbitrary , holds. But for , does not have a solution. This is contradictory. So it is not possible for the real or complex matrix that Ran Ker .
Comments
-
This solution is incorrect, the result can be true for complex matrices, for example the one in the previous exercise. Note that in this proof $A^TAv=0$ does not necessarily imply $A=0$ if $A$ is complex.introspectiveSwallow • 2024-08-15